17 July 2016

To Be a Pilgrim: II. Departure

A four-part series on the Christian life as pilgrimage. 

I.  Summons
II. Departure
III. Getting There
IV. Return

Genesis 12: 1-9

9th Sunday after Pentecost

17th July 2016

Pilgrim.  It sounds so antiquated.  Exotic.  Odd.  The thought of being or becoming a pilgrim seems strange, even weird. 

There was a time when pilgrimage was an integral part of the Christian life. During the Middle Ages pilgrims traipsed all over Europe, and beyond, going to places of historic and spiritual significance, often to do penance.  They walked to Jerusalem, Rome, Santiago de Compostela in Spain, Canterbury, St. Andrews.  The Protestant Reformation put the kibosh on pilgrimage, especially in Northern Europe.  However, an interest in pilgrimage is on the rise in Europe.  Last year, more than 750,000 pilgrims walked across Spain to Santiago de Compostela. Even more will walk this year.  Former pilgrim ways have reopened, such as the St. Olav Ways to Trondheim in Norway, or the Way of St.Andrews, which goes from Isle of Iona in the west straight across Scotland to St. Andrews on the North Sea.  Many walk for religious reasons. Some walk just for the sense of adventure.  Many are spiritual seekers, with no religious affiliation, searching for something more, something more than life in the West has to offer, with its materialism and commercialism and superficial spirituality that doesn’t speak to the soul.

So much of this interest in pilgrimage is completely alien to North American Christians.  As Protestants, we have no tradition of pilgrimage in our faith experience.  There are no temples or shrines, no sacred grottos or groves for Protestants flock to.  Even American Roman Catholics, for the most part, are missing this aspect of their spirituality here in the United States.

It was through the writings of my friend Ian Bradley, in St. Andrews, decades ago, that I was first introduced to the importance of pilgrimage in Celtic Christianity.[1]  Since then, the life of the pilgrim, the meaning of pilgrimage, have shaped my understanding of the Christian life.  I might not talk about it much, but it stands at the center of my faith.  Being a pilgrim is essentially saying that the Christian life is about a journey, walking with Christ, being on the way with the one who said he was Way (John 14:6).  The earliest followers of Jesus were not known as Christians but simply followers of The Way (Acts 9:2).  And, as I shared last week, there are times when I wish we didn’t have the designation “Christian.”  It’s a word that has so much baggage—and pilgrims travel light.  What if Christians were known simply as people of the Way?  Then we would have a more dynamic, active understanding of life in Christ.

An active, dynamic, fluid understanding of the Christian life is a way of saying that a follower of Jesus is always on a journey.  Jesus invited us to walk with him. “Come, follow me,” Jesus said. Come. Walk with me on the road to life, true life, meaningful life, full life. The journey is life; life is the journey.  If you’re breathing, if you’re baptized, then you’re already on the journey. 

God’s people are always on the move.  Adam and Eve left the garden and fell into the world.  Abram and Sarai were summoned to leave home and venture into new territory.  Moses and Miriam led the Israelites out of slavery in Egypt and then walked for forty years through the wilderness.  Mary and Joseph traveled to a new place for Jesus to be born.  The so-called Prodigal Son left home and returned (Luke 15).  Jesus spent his entire life on the road with “no place to lay his head” (Matthew 8:20), and walked through Jerusalem to a cross.  Then the same Jesus met his friends on Easter evening—where?  On the road to Emmaus (Luke 24).  The apostle Paul was summoned to preach in Europe (Acts 16:9).  It’s all about the journey. The Spanish mystic Teresa of Avila (1515-1582) even wondered, remarkably, “The feeling remains that God is on the journey too.”


It’s important to say that by journey we don’t mean a vacation or being a tourist.  It’s not a synonym for traveling.  To see our lives as a journey or pilgrimage is different because what we’re essentially talking about here is a process of change, of transformation.  Mark Nepo writes in his book The Exquisite Risk, “To journey without being changed is to be a nomad.  To change without journeying is to be a chameleon.  To journey and be transformed by the journey is to be a pilgrim.”[2] 

So, what is a pilgrim and why would you want to be one?  John O’Donohue (1956-2008), the Irish priest and philosopher, who died much too soon, left us with one answer.  “Ideally,” he said, “a human life should be a constant pilgrimage of discovery. The most exciting discoveries happen at the frontiers.  When you come to know something new, you come closer to yourself and to the world.  Discovery enlarges and refines your sensibility. When you discover something, you transfigure some of the forsakenness of the world.”[3]

The journey has a structure, a pattern.  It’s deep, archetypal, embedded in the soul.  It often has four stages: summons (which we explored last week), departure, getting there, and return.  And, I should add, there isn’t one journey, but many journeys throughout one’s life.  The pattern repeats itself over and over again.  We never return the same, which then opens us up to being summoned to something new.

And once you’ve been summoned…you have to move!  You depart.  Every journey requires leaving home.  The quintessential example of this leave-taking is the call to Abram and Sarai and their eventual departure.  It doesn’t get any clearer than this:  “Go from your country and your kindred and your father’s house to the land that I will show you” (Genesis 12:1).  One word: Go.  Abram had to leave home in order to get to that new land, in order to experience the blessing.  The blessing could not to be found at home, where he was rooted.  He had to pull up his roots, sever his ties to the land, his family, his heritage.  If he latched on to any of these they would have held him back, cause him to get stuck, unable to move toward the place of blessing. And it was essential for him and for his family—and for his future descendants—that he go.  And, if you think about it, it was essential for us, for you and me today—that he went. Think of it, the entire Biblical narrative hinges on Abram and Sarai’s decision to go, to leave, depart.  “So Abram went,” scripture says, “as Yahweh had told him” (Genesis 12:4).

Eventually, we have to depart, we have to leave and step out into the future.  It took Abram three verses to go from summons to departure.  He just did what he was told.   Perhaps this is why Abram was praised for his faith and declared righteous (Genesis 15:6; Romans 4:3).  He knew that Yahweh could be trusted.

Now, Abram might be a good model for us to emulate, but that doesn’t means this is easy.  What’s missing in these three verses is everything that went through his head and heart, and Sarai’s, when he heard the word to “Go.”  How much time elapse between summons and departure?  Did he doubt himself?  Was he fearful?  Did Sarah say, “What, are you crazy?”  Did they quarrel?  What kind of anguish did they endure?  We need to remember that, yes, Abram and Sarai, along with Lot, ventured with all of their possessions, we’re told.  But “the greater significance is not what they [brought] with them but with what they [left] behind.” They would never see their family and clan again.  In a tribal society leaving family was like death—at least that’s what it must have felt like.  They were sent to an alien landscape. God says to them, effectively, “Abram and Sarai, go and become aliens.”  Or, better, “Become strangers!”   In other words, become pilgrims. 

Christine Painter reminds us, “Journeys are movements from one place to another, often to a place that is unfamiliar, foreign, and strange.  In fact, the Latin root of the word pilgrimage, peregrini, means ‘strange’ or ‘stranger.’  The journey,” she says, “to become a pilgrim means becoming a stranger in the service of transformation.”[4] And in order for transformation to occur we are sent out from the familiar into the unknown.  “A pilgrimage,” Painter writes, “is an intentional journey into this experience of unknowing and discomfort for the sake of stripping away preconceived expectations.  We grow closer to God beyond our own imagination and ideas.”[5]

And if this act of departure, of crossing the threshold into that liminal space between the known and unknown seems scary—it is.  It’s full of anxiety.  It’s easier to recoil from the call, ignore the summons, stay home.  This is how I’m feeling, to be honest, about my upcoming sabbatical, especially the Camino, the 500-mile trek across Spain to Santiago.  I’m both excited and anxious and doubting.  Do I really want to do this?  Is this how I want to spend my sabbatical, walking for forty days?  There’s a pull in me that just wants to stay home, read on my porch, tend my garden (which needs tending), hike along the Patapsco and not deal with packing and planning for being away for almost three months. Sometimes the summons overwhelms us and we’re tired even before we begin.  But I know where all these feelings come from.

My good friend James Hollis writes, beautifully, about what is at stake in such moments.  Jim is a psychoanalyst and writer, now based in DC.  He say, “Our being inevitably depends upon repeated separations, repeated developmental departures, ever farther away from the archaic, safe place. Drifting as we do through the gossamer dance of life, we are flooded with nostalgia, a word whose Greek origin means ‘pain for home.’  When the desire to ‘go home,’ [or stay home,] prevails,” he says, “we will choose not to choose, rest easy in the saddle, remain amid the familiar and comfortable, even when it is stultifying and soul-denying.” Jim reminds us, “Each morning the twin gremlins of fear and lethargy sit at the foot of our bed and smirk.  Fear of further departure, fear of the unknown, fear of the challenge of largeness intimidates us back into our convenient rituals, conventional thinking, and familiar surroundings.  To be recurrently intimidated by the tasks of life is a form of spiritual annihilation.  On the other front, lethargy seduces us with sibilant whispers:  kick back, chill out, numb out, take it easy for a while…sometimes for a long while, sometimes a lifetime, sometimes a spiritual oblivion.”[6]

But the Spirit of God summons us to life!  Go, leave, depart, move into the future, to the “land,” to the place of blessing.  You can’t get there by staying put.  You can’t get there if you give into anxiety and worry and fear.  I think Carl Jung (1875-1961) is correct when he says, “The spirit of evil is fear, negation…the spirit of regression, who threatens us with bondage to the mother…”[7] By “mother” he’s not referring to one’s literal parent, but what “she” can symbolize, “the safe and sheltering harbor: the old job, the familiar warm arms, and the same unchallenged, and stultifying, value system.  Family and heritage and clan can also have this “mothering” role; these are not inherently bad, but to be dominated by their pull “means that we are in service to sleep, not the tasks of life, to security, not development.”[8] 

The call of God is not to security, but to growth and development, transformation.  Jung said, “Fear is a challenge and a task, because only boldness can deliver from fear. And if the risk is not taken, the meaning of life is somehow violated.”  Can you imagine how the history of the world would have been different had Abram and Sarai not risked departure?  What if they just stayed home?

We can talk and write eloquently about the task, but when it comes down to it, we just have to do it. We have to act. When we’re reluctant to step out, perhaps we just need to remember that song from Santa Claus is Coming to Town.  You remember.  You know it from the 1970 Rankin/Bass stop motion animation Christmas special.  There’s a scene in which Kris Kringle tries to get the Winter Warlock to change his nasty ways.  Kris Kringle helps him step out into a new way of living.  What’s his advice?  What does Kris Kringle say or sing?

Put one foot in front of the other
And soon you’ll be walking ‘cross the floor.
You put one foot in front of the other
And soon you’ll be walking out the door.

You never will get where you’re going
If ya never get up on your feet.[9]

Put one foot in front of the other—and then another and another and another.

That’s how we get to where we need to go.








[1] See Ian Bradley, The Celtic Way (London: Darton, Longman, & Todd, 2004); Pilgrimage: A Spiritual and Cultural Journey (London: Lion Hudson, 2010).
[2] Cited in Christine Valters Painter, The Soul of a Pilgrim: Eight Practices for the Journey Within (Notre Dame, IN: Sorin Books, 2015), 1.
[3] John O’Donohue, Eternal Echoes:  Celtic Reflections on Our Yearning to Belong (Harper Perennial, 2000), 20.
[4] Painter, 1-2.
[5] Painter, 2.
[6] James Hollis, Finding Meaning in the Second Half of Life: How to Finally, Really Grow Up (New York: Gotham Books, 2006), 38-39.
[7] C. G. Jung, Symbols of Transformation, Vol. 5, par. 551 in The Collected Works, trans. R. F. C. Hull (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1973).
[8] This is Hollis reflecting on the quotation from Jung, 39.
[9] “Put One Foot in Front of the Other,” Santa Claus is Coming to Town (Rankin/Bass, 1970). Music by Maury Laws; text by Jules Bass. 

10 July 2016

To Be a Pilgrim: I. Summons

A four-part series on the Christian life as pilgrimage. 

I. Summons
II. Departure
III. Getting There
IV. Return

Luke 5:1-11

10th July 2016

Pilgrim.  From the Latin peregrinus, meaning “foreign.”  The word describes what one becomes when one ventures into new lands.  A pilgrim is a foreigner, a stranger, a wayfarer, someone from the outside, from some place else, from abroad, traveling through.

A pilgrim travels, but not as a tourist.  She’s on the road, he’s on the way and that road, that way is holy.  The way is sacred.  The destination is sacred.  The return is sacred. 

Why does a pilgrim travel?  Why go on a pilgrimage?   Because there are things about one’s faith and life and the meaning of one’s life and faith that can only be discovered after we leave home for a time and explore unknown territory.  There are things we can only discover when we’re on the road, on the way.  That unknown territory can be in the outer world, just beyond the horizon or that unknown territory can be the world within.  In either place we are strangers to others or strangers to ourselves.  The journey in the outer world opens up the journey of the inner world.  The inner journey then shapes how we journey though the outer world.  One informs the others.

In his remarkable book The Art of Pilgrimage, Phil Cousineau reminds us that “we are all strangers in this world and that part of the elusive wonder of travel is that in those moments far away from the familiar, we are forced to face that truth, which is to say, the sacred truth of our soul’s journey here on earth.”  He says, “This is one reason the stranger has always been held in awe and why the stranger on the move is perpetually a soul in wonder.”[1]

A stranger on the move.  That’s a pretty good definition of a pilgrim.  A perpetual soul in wonder.  American theologian Richard R. Niebuhr elegantly described a pilgrim this way:  “Pilgrims are persons in motion—passing through territories not their own—seeking something we might call completion, or perhaps the word clarity will do as well, a goal to which on the spirit’s compass points the way.”[2]

There’s something within the human spirit, in the human heart that resonates with pilgrim life.  We hunger to embark on a meaningful journey, a journey that feeds our souls and makes our hearts sing, a journey that brings us to life. The early Celtic Christians of Wales, Ireland, and Scotland, for example, often went on pilgrimage or peregrination.  The Celts traveled all over Europe.  Sometimes they got into little boats or coracles and just set off for sea, never sure where they would end up.  Some of them never returned.  They went searching, as they said, “seeking the place of one’s resurrection.”[3] 

Pilgrimage is a sacred adventure, which involves some risk. This is what the experience of pilgrimage speaks to—adventure, adventure of the soul.  It’s “a transformative journey to a sacred center.”[4]  We find this desire in all the major religions of the world, in Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity, and Islam.  Pilgrimage, Cousineau writes, “calls for a journey to a holy site associated with gods, saints, or heroes, or to a natural setting imbued with spiritual power, or to a revered temple to seek counsel.  To people the world over, pilgrimage is a spiritual exercise, an act of devotion to find a source of healing, or even to perform a penance.  Always, it is a journey of risk and renewal.  For a journey without challenge has no meaning; one with purpose has no soul.”

So much of this experience is completely alien to North American Christians, especially Protestants.  We have no tradition of pilgrimage in our faith experience.  There are no temples, shrines, grottos or sacred groves that we Protestants flock to.  Even American Roman Catholics are missing this aspect of their spirituality here in the United States.  The Sanctuario de Chimayo, just north of Sante Fe, NM, is one possible exception (there are probably others).  The sand or dirt in the chapel there apparently has healing properties.  To our Protestant ears, pilgrim and pilgrimage sound so antiquated, quaint. We think of Plymouth pilgrims with their buckled shoes and tall black hats and turkeys.  The Protestant Reformation put the kibosh on pilgrimage, especially in Northern Europe, where it thrived throughout the Middle Ages.

I have to admit, being a pilgrim, going off on pilgrimage was a foreign concept to me.  That all changed when I moved to Scotland after seminary.  It was in Scotland that I came to learn about the importance of pilgrimage in Celtic Christianity.  And then, living in St. Andrews, the importance of pilgrimage in medieval Europe was evident.  St. Andrews was one of the major pilgrim sites in Europe. The cathedral, one of the largest in Europe, contained several bones that belonged (so the story goes) to Andrew.  Christians walked and then sailed and walked some more from all over Europe to visit St. Andrews.  Everything in the town was arranged to accommodate the countless pilgrims that traveled to this little town or burgh on the coast of the North Sea.  During the Reformation, the Protestants destroyed the cathedral and then threw the relics in the rubbish bin.  Today, followers of the golf gods make pilgrimages to St. Andrews, the home of golf, to pay homage to the 18th fairway.  Although, there are plans underway to create a new pilgrim way to St. Andrews, right across the Kingdom of Fife.

Since my time in Scotland pilgrimage has come to mean a lot to me.  The image might be overused, but I do believe that the Christian life is a journey. A Christian is a pilgrim.  This spirit of adventure, struggle, and exploration was beautifully captured in the words of John Bunyan (1628-1688), found in the hymn Who Would True Valour See:      

Who would true valour see,
let him come hither;
one here will constant be,
come wind, come weather;
there’s no discouragement
shall make him once relent
his first avowed intent
to be a pilgrim. [5]

I was first introduced to this hymn by Lawson Brown, the minister I served under at St. Leonard’s Parish Church in St. Andrews, a dear friend and mentor.  It was one of his favorite hymns and it’s a favorite of mine.

I might not talk about it a lot, but this image of the Christian as pilgrim stands at the center of my faith.  That’s why I put it at the center of my sabbatical grant proposal, which was graciously granted.  Thank you, Lilly Clergy Renewal Program!  To Be a Pilgrim:  A Journey of the Heart, Soul, and Spirit – that’s the title I gave to the grant application.  I should have added body, because as every pilgrim knows, “our eyes are in our feet.”[6]  The theme for the sabbatical time is pilgrimage.  I will travel to familiar places that feed my soul, such as Scotland, and visit new places that I dreamt about seeing as boy, and then walk the ancient pilgrimage route across Spain, a 500-mile trek to Santiago de Compostela, which houses the remains of the St. James (so the story goes).  And while I’m away, CPC will be exploring pilgrimage in various ways, including a walk to the National Cathedral in Washington, DC.

I believe that the Christian life is a journey.  Every follower of Christ, by virtue of one’s baptism, is called, summoned on an adventure to discover the sacred core of one’s life and the meaning and purpose of such a life.  It’s one big journey from birth through life to death to new life.  And along the way there are countless journeys that make up the call of our lives.  But what matters most along the way is that we hear the call, discovering the purpose of our lives as we walk through space-time.

Remember, the early followers of Jesus were not called Christians, but simply The Way (see Acts 9:2).  They were followers of the Way, followers of the one who said he was Way (John 14:6).   He is the road, which means that we when we are with him we are on the way to some other place.  He’s both leading the way and knows the way and we are called to follow, to walk with him.  Such an understanding of the Christian life allows our experience to be inherently dynamic, moving, never, ever static.  We’re not supposed to stand still, but to move.  What if we were not known as Christians, but as followers of the Way?  Perhaps then we would have a more dynamic, active understanding of our life in Christ.  T. S. Eliot (1888-1965) gets at this when he said, in Four Quartets, we ought to be explorers,

We must be still and still moving into another intensity,
For a further union, a deeper communion...

And the way has a pattern, four stages (roughly):  summons, departure, getting there, and then return. We find this pattern at work in the lives of God’s people.  Whether the journey is inward or outward, the pattern remains the same.

It all begins with a summons, an invitation, and a call, even a longing.  The Spirit speaks to us through a hunch, a feeling, a thought, a desire, a dream.  The Spirit evokes something in us through a tug on the heart, or maybe tears, or anger, or rage, or passion, or frustration, or sadness, or pain.  It could be through the voice of a loved one, a friend, even a stranger, something that strikes you, catches you, grips you and holds you, something that eventually causes your feet to move.  The Spirit moves you off dead center and then sends you.  Time and again we discover that God moves us so that we then move, to do something we would not otherwise attempt or have ever dreamt of doing, something we would rather not attempt to do.  It might even make us uncomfortable, probably will.

One of my favorite stories is the calling of Simon, here in Luke 5.  They’ve been out on the Sea of Galilee all night, fishing, and hadn’t caught a thing.  It’s easy to think of this story as being only about evangelism, about “catching people.”  It does have something to say about catching people, but before we get there Simon has to do what Jesus asked him to do.  Simon has been summoned to do something, something he’s reluctant. 

“Look, Master, we’ve been out here all night long and didn’t catch a thing.  We’re tired.  And there are all those people who keep following you around.  We just want to go home.” 

And what did Jesus ask him do?  “Put out into the deep water and let down your nets for a catch” (Luke 5:4).   That’s the call.  Put out into the deep water.  And then let down your down nets, into the depths, for a catch.  And when they did so they had so many fish that their nets began to break. They signaled for help.  And then they filled two boats to capacity with fish that both boats almost started to sink under the weight.  Overwhelmed by the abundance of the depths!

And what does Peter say?  It’s too much!  All of this is too much!  He fell down at his feet and said, “Go away from me, Lord, for I am a sinful man!”  Or, in other words, “Go away from me, Lord, for I am not worthy of this.”  But obviously he was.

Sometimes we don’t want to be summoned.  Sometimes we don’t want to be called, we don’t want to experience the Holy, we don’t want to experience the abundance.  Sure, we say we do.  We think we do.  But there’s a part of us that recoils from our capacity.  This is because we know that every experience of the Holy carries an obligation to do something about it.  It might cause us to change—change the way we see the world, God, and ourselves.  It might cause us to change the direction of our lives.  It might cause us to change professions, leave everything behind in order to walk with him.  Note that Jesus didn’t ask him to leave everything behind.  That was Simon’s decision.  But he knew he had to leave behind something in order to take up this new call.

Henry David Thoreau (1817-1862) knew something about being called.  He invited us to pay attention to what’s going on within the soul.  Does the call cause us to contract in fear or calls us to expand.  There’s always some fear, even in an expansive call.  Is the call confining or expansive?  Thoreau wrote, “We do not commonly live our life out and full; we do not fill all our pores with our blood; we do not inspire and expire fully and entirely enough….  We live but a fraction of our life. We do we not let in the flood, raise the gates, and set all our wheels in motion?”[7] 

We are, too often, like Peter who was ready to give up on the call, overwhelmed by the abundance, overwhelmed by life, overwhelmed by the challenges facing us or what God expects from us.  It can feel all too much for us.  So we give it back to God or we shut down, or turn off the television, unplug, run from responsibility, go back to bed and pull the covers over our heads.

To what am I being summoned?  
To what are you being summoned? 
Where are we as a church being summoned? 

After the horrific events this week in Baton Rouge, St. Paul, and then Dallas, what are we being summoned to as a nation, as people of faith?  You see, how you/we respond to the world around us might also tell us something about our call, of what is being asked of us, what difficult task we are being asked to take on.  What are you being asked by God to do in light of these shootings?  What next step on the journey of faith are you being called to? 

I can’t answer these questions.  It’s up to you.  At least one thing is for sure: if you’re breathing you’ve been summoned.   I can’t tell you to what and to where.  Maybe you need to put out into the depths and let down your nets for a catch.  Or maybe you need to take a walk, a very long walk.  As every pilgrim knows, that’s what the journey’s for.  That’s what the road provides.  Augustine (354-430) said, Solvitur ambulando.  “It is solved by walking.” 

The French poet Jules Supervielle (1884-1960) writes in his poem, The Call: 
            And it was then that in the depths of sleep
            Someone breathed to me:
            “You alone can do it, Come immediately.[8]

And so we go.








[1] Phil Cousineau, The Art of Pilgrimage: The Seeker’s Guide to Making Travel Sacred, Foreword by Huston Smith (Conari Press, 1998), xx.
[2] Cited in Cousineau, 14.
[3] Ian Bradley, The Celtic Way (London: Darton, Longman,  & Todd, 1993), 77.
[4] Cousineau, xxiii.
[5] Who Would True Valour See.  Text:  John Bunyan. Tune:  MONKS GATE, written by Ralph Vaughan Williams, originally appeared in The English Hymnal 1906.
[6] Nan Shepherd, The Living Mountain (1977).
[7] Cited in Cousineau, 17.
[8] Cited in Cousineau, 29.