21 May 2017

The Work of Love

John 14:15-24

Sixth Sunday of Easter

In John’s remarkable Gospel, the community that gathers around Jesus is summoned to love. “If you love me,” Jesus said, “you will keep my commandments” (Jn. 14:15).  You.  The “you” is plural in the Greek.  So, a better translation would be, “you all” or, better still, “y’all.” “If y’all love me, y’all will keep my commandments.”  Jesus is talking to his disciples, he’s talking to a community of followers.  We’re the “y’all,” the church, you and me.  “If y’all love me, y’all keep my commandments.”

Unlike the other Gospels (Matthew, Mark, Luke), John circles around a center point.  The Gospel circumambulates, that is, moves around in a circuit that leads to and flows from a center.  And that center is love.  Not generic love.  Not love as romantic feeling or sentiment.  That center is love, God’s love: God’s fierce and tender love enfleshed in human form, embodied in Jesus the Christ.  Love is the center and the ground of everything.  “For God so loved the world that God gave his only Son, so that everyone who believes (or trusts) in him may not perish but may have eternal life” (Jn. 3:16). Even stronger is the next verse, which tells us what God’s love does: “For God sent the Son, not to condemn the world, but that the world might be saved through him” (Jn. 3:17).

In fact, John uses love verbs (agapao and phileo) fifty-seven times in his Gospel.  Matthew, thirteen times; Mark, six; Luke, fifteen.  The noun love (agape) is used seven times in John; Matthew and Luke use it once, and Mark never.  Friend (philos) appears six times in John; Matthew uses it once, Mark never, and Luke fifteen times. Only in John’s Gospels is philos, “friend,” used to describe Jesus’ followers. Jesus’ closest friend in John’s Gospel is known as the Beloved Disciple or the “one whom Jesus loved.”  Love is central to John’s understanding of Jesus.  It can’t be any clearer.  Love is what characterizes a follower of Jesus.

It’s so simple.  Why, then is it so difficult?  Christians aren’t the only loving people in the world, but we at least ought to be people known for our unique ability to love.  Shouldn’t we? We read in 1 John, “God is love, and those who abide in love abide in God, and God abides in them” (1 Jn. 4:16b). If we claim a belief in God, if we identify as believers and followers, and if God is love, and we’re abiding in God, remain close to God, close in intimacy with God through prayer and action, then love should be more evident in the body of the Church.  And, yet, the history of the Church is marred with so much blood and sin and hatred and shallow, fearful thinking.  We have much in our history and in the present Church that needs mercy, pardon, and grace.  The Church has been complicit in countless atrocities over the centuries.  We need to repent and confess the wrong we have done.  And, in our age, the words “Christian” and “loving” are not synonymous for many—and we only have ourselves to blame.

Two weeks ago, today, I was in St. Andrews, Scotland, and went for a walk with friends down the East Sands, along the coast of Fife, with the North Sea stretching out before us.  It was the day after the funeral of my dear friend, Margaret Murray.  A group of us, mostly Murray family members, people I have known for twenty-seven years, talked about many things as we walked.  Eventually, the subject turned to Christianity and the Kirk, or the Church, in Scotland.  One comment has stayed with me.  It was said by friend Mark, a chap with a keen mind and sharp perception.  He said, “I blame the Church, especially the Church of the last five hundred years,” that is, since the Reformation, “for much that is wrong in Scotland today.”  That’s quite a statement.  He still sees himself as part of the Kirk and attends worship now and again.  His father was a Church of Scotland (Presbyterian) minister (whom I knew).  His mother is a member of the Iona Community.  So, Mark knows the Kirk, intimately, especially as a child of the manse.  I wish we had more time to talk.  I wanted to go deeper.  I agreed with him—in part. In many places, the Church is hurting and Christianity is struggling.  I wouldn’t blame the Church, however, for all that is wrong in Scotland.  There is a lot of good in the Kirk today and Scotland is a remarkable nation.  However, the Church has a lot to answer for; it isn’t innocent.  This is true in Scotland and here in the United States, anywhere, for that matter.

Yes, I know, the Church is not perfect because it’s made up of imperfect, broken, wounded people.  As a minister, I know all too well about the fallenness of human nature.  The human heart can be a dark and destructive place.  “All have sinned and fallen short of the glory of God” (Romans 3:23), especially me.  “Sin abounds” (Romans 5:20).  But this language about fallenness and sin and falling short of God’s glory is the language of the Apostle Paul.  And while Paul might be correct about sin, it’s remarkable that in John’s Gospel, sin is mentioned many times, but the emphasis is elsewhere.  It’s about something else entirely. 

Jesus focuses on love.  In fact, in John’s Gospel, Jesus tells us that we have the capacity within us to love as he loved.  Jesus invites us to dwell or abide or rest in his love—to drop into his love—and live in the love that he knows and experiences when he dwells, abides, rests, drops into the love of his Father, when he abides in the love of God.  Jesus tells us that if we abide in his love, connect in and through and with this love, we are abiding in God’s love.  It’s all about the relationship.  John offers a relational theology.  And, Jesus insists that when we are abiding in his love and God’s love, we will be given the capacity to love as Jesus loved.  In fact, Jesus tells us—only in John’s Gospel do we hear—that we will do even greater works, greater than Jesus, when we abide in and with Jesus, who abides in God. 

It’s right here in John 14:12: “Very truly, I tell you, the one who believes in me will also do the works that I do and, in fact, will do greater works than these….”

Let this sink in for a moment.  Go ahead.  I mean it.  Let it sink in.  Listen to this Word—not in your heads, but in your hearts.  “Very truly, I tell you, the one who believes in me will also do the works that I do and, in fact, will do greater works than these….” 

Allow this to sink into your psyche, to settle into your soul. 

Greater works.

It’s stunning to consider how much God trusts us and entrusts to us, how much confidence God has in us, how much God counts on us, and equips us, and expects from us.  Jesus doesn’t say, “To those who are perfect or really good or sinless, I will trust with my work.”  We might say this to ourselves.  Jesus doesn’t.  We might think these things.  When we hear God’s call in our lives—whatever the call might be—we might say, not I.  Not me.  Not us.  I don’t know enough.  I’m not good enough.  I’m not wise enough.  I’m not enough enough.  Not with my past.  Not with the things that I’ve done.  But Jesus never says this to his followers.  Jesus keeps it simple.  Yet we want to complicate things.  We’re good with coming up with all kinds of excuses for why God can’t love us or call us.  Jesus says: love.  We want to make it complex.  But, why do we like to make things more difficult than they really are?  Why do we make Christianity so difficult?  Why do we make Church so difficult?  Maybe that’s where our sin-nature takes over and carts us off into exile away from God, our neighbors, the church, ourselves. These are all defensive excuses and strategies that we hide behind.

“Greater works than these,” Jesus says to us.  “Whether we will do them is up to us; the fact that we can do them is because Jesus accomplished what he set out to do (Jn. 19:30),”[1] and now sends the Holy Spirit to accompany us in the work that is placed before us.  What is clear, here, is that there’s “no room for disciples of Jesus to dream small.”[2] And, yet, consider how many of us prefer to live small lives.  Lives that are too small for us, lives that prevent us living toward our capacity.  As the psychiatrist C. G. Jung (1875-1961) observed, “Most of us walk in shoes that are too small for us.”  The call of Jesus in our lives, however, is always toward greater love, toward greater enlargement, greater expansion of our hearts, our vision, our call; the call is never, ever toward diminishment. Never. Never. Never.

“If you love me,” Jesus said, “you will keep my commandments.” Now, we need to hear this verse from within John’s theological framework. When we hear the word “commandments” we probably think of the Ten Commandments, as well as the many sayings of Jesus throughout the Gospels, especially the parables.  You might think of all the things that Jesus tells us we’re supposed to do as his followers.  Such as, “Take up your cross and follow” (Luke 9:23).  But, you won’t find this in John.  “Be perfect, as your heavenly Father is perfect” (Matthew 5:8).  You won’t find this in John.  “Forgive, not seven times, but seventy-seven times seven” (Matthew 18:22).  You won’t find this in John either.  Ironically, in John’s Gospel we don’t have a long list of things we ought to do our not do.  There are no commandments.[3] 

Actually, there is one commandment.  The only commandment that Jesus gives in John is this one: “I give you a new commandment, that you love one another. Just as I have loved you, you also should love one another.  By this everyone will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another” (Jn. 13:34-35).  “Love one another.”  That’s it.  So simple.  So profound.  Everything in John’s Gospel revolves around this command, this teaching.

This commandment is given because Jesus believes we are capable of actually loving one another, with his aid, otherwise why would he give it to us?  To suggest otherwise would be cruel.  We can’t love this way on our own, but we have the capacity to do so.  And, so in love Jesus sends a helper, an Advocate, the Holy Spirit, also known as the Paraclete, the parakletos.  The Paraclete means someone who is at our side, someone who comes alongside us and helps us, walks with us, encourages us, supports us, advocates for us, challenges us, enables us to live deeply in Christ.  We can’t love the way Jesus loves on our own.  Even if we have the capacity to love one another, that doesn’t mean that we do or want to, and certainly not all the time.  We need help.  Jesus says that he won’t leave us “orphans” (Jn. 14:18).

“Those who have my commandments,” Jesus says, “and keeps them are those who love me; and those who love me will be loved by my Father, and I will love them and reveal myself to them” (Jn. 14:21).

And even the command to love, itself, is given in love! The command is not given to make our lives more difficult.  It’s given so that we can have richer, fuller lives, abundant lives—not in things, but in spirit, abundant in love (see Jn. 10:10).

And love is work.  We have to work at it.  Yes, the Spirit enables us.  Yes, grace is at work.  But we are also called to act, to work, to use our God-given capacities to live out our full humanity, the way Jesus used his God-given capacities and lived out his full humanity.  It’s work.  Ergo, in Greek, “work,” from which we get ergonomic.  Jesus is describing ergonomic love.

We have to do our part.  We have to bring ourselves to bear upon this work.  We can’t be passive.  We don’t love when we feel like it.  Love is not always contingent upon feelings.  Years ago, a wise Franciscan brother reminded me that “Love is a choice.”  We choose to love.  It’s a verb.  It requires action.  And a lot depends upon what we bring to the moment.

It’s been said, “All you need is love. Love is all you need.”  But, how do we love one another?  How do we do the work of love?  How does the Church increase its capacity to love?  How do we exercise this love here in community and beyond this community, in our relationships, our families, our neighbors, strangers we meet, colleagues at work.  How are y’all increasing your love for one another?

My friend Sören Kierkegaard (1813-1855) reflected deeply on the nature of Christian love.  He said, “Our duty is to love those we see.”[4]  Our task is not to find the lovable object or person and then love.  A change of perspective is needed, a changed heart, in which we bring our love to bear upon an object or person that we, at first glance, might consider unlovable.[5]  We need clarity of perception in order to see. We don’t find the perfect person to love.  Love transforms how we see the other, allows the other to come into focus, not some idealized form, but the real thing.  You see the other with all her imperfections and flaws, you see the other with all his weaknesses and sins, and you love nevertheless.[6]

The practical theologian James Loder (1931-2011), taught me much about how God loves us and he taught me so much about how to love.  He said, “Love is the non-possessive delight in the particularly of the other.”[7]  It’s one of the best definitions I know.  Love can’t be possessive. If you’re going to delight in the particularly, in the uniqueness of the other, you need to see the other.  Love requires attention.  And love requires intention.  It’s a work.  Love is a verb, which means that we have to bring something of ourselves into the exchange.  You have to bring yourself, fully, to the moment, to the person, to the situation, to the circumstance. 

Several years ago, I was introduced to the writings of Kathleen Raine (1908-2003), a poet, a scholar of William Blake (1757-1827), a child of the manse. There’s one insight that I came across that took my breath away. She said, “Unless you see a thing in the light of love, you do not see a thing at all.”[8]  Just meditate on this insight for a while and let this sink in too. 

Love is the light that illumines the darkness, it’s that which allows us to see.  This means that without love our vision is distorted, even blind. We might think we see or know someone, but unless our gaze is mediated through love, then s/he remains invisible to us.  Without intentional love, all we see is what we project onto people, our wishful thinking, what we fantasize them to be, what we want them to be, or we project our fears, maybe even our hate. Through love a thing, a person, even God, comes into focus, becomes visible. Imagine this as the way God sees you, through love.  In love God really sees us and we know ourselves loved for having been truly seen. 

Try it yourself.  If you never really see a thing apart from love, then bring the full capacity of your love, work at it—ask the Holy Spirit to help you!—bring your full intention to something or someone, love it, love her, love him, love the stranger, love your enemy, love your fear, love your anxiety, love your grief, love yourself, love God, and then watch how your perception changes, if not in the moment, then over time.

Speaking of Jim Loder, in addition to being a theologian and professor, he was also a remarkable counselor who weaved together psychology and theology as he counseled students (including me) at Princeton Seminary. Jim shared with me the story of a woman who was plagued by dreams of a monster who was trying to attack her.  The images were debilitating.  Working with Loder, she did imaginal work with the dream. He invited her to go back into the dream, to face the monster coming after her. Then, fully supporting her in this experience, he invited her to love the monster, to have compassion toward the monster, to keep loving it. So she loved the monster.  And then it happened, in her imagination, the monster engulfed in love, split open, and inside was a frightened little child who was also in need of a lot of love.  The monster never returned in her dreams.  She came to love that inner child.  It was a turning point in her therapeutic experience.  “Unless you see a thing in the light of love, you do not see a thing at all.”

Everything comes back to love.  To the center.  “If you love me, you will keep my commandments.” And his command is that we love.  Because we can.  Because the world needs us—needs y’all—to love.  Because the work that God is calling us to do with our lives requires nothing less than all the love we can give—and then some.
           

-->




[1] Jaime Clark-Soles, Reading John for Dear Life: A Spiritual Walk with the Fourth Gospel (Louisville: Westminster John Knox Press, 2016), 95.
[2] Clark-Soles, 95.
[3] Jaime Clark-Soles, 96.
[4] Sören Kierkegaard, The Works of Love: Some Christian Reflections in the Form of Discourses (New York: Harper Torchbooks, 1962 [1847]), 153ff.
[5] Kierkegaard, 158.
[6] Kierkegaard, 170.
[7] See Kenneth E. Kovacs, The Relational Theology of James E. Loder: Encounter and Conviction (New York: Peter Lang, 2011).
[8] Cited in John O’Donohue, Änam Cara: A Book of Celtic Wisdom (Harper Perennial, 1998), 65. I also recommend The Collected Poems of Kathleen Raine (Washington, DC: Counterpoint, 2001), and Kathleen Raine, William Blake (New York: Thames and Hudson, 2000).

30 April 2017

Inhaling the Holy

John 20:19-31

Third Sunday after Easter

Robert Pirsig died last Monday, at 88.  He was the author of Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance: An Inquiry into Values, a brilliant novel full of ideas and deeply disturbing, in many respects.  It became an unlikely publishing phenomenon in the 1970s, when it was first published.  The novel, part road trip, part treatise, part open letter to a younger generation, tries to reconcile humanism with technological progress. It navigates through the world of ideas, especially Plato, trying to reach an age such as ours, an age that has become obsessed with technology and materialism, alienated from the life of the soul, alienated from what he calls Quality, which could be could understood as God.  Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance unfolds as a fictionalized account of a cross-country motorcycle trip that Pirsig took in 1968 with his 11-year-old son, Christopher, and two friends.  The novel navigates through complex ideas that explore the relationship of humans and machines, the nature of madness, and the roots of culture. Pirsig was diagnosed with schizophrenia in the 1960s and said that the book was written to make peace with himself after two years of hospital treatments, and the turmoil that he, his wife, and children suffered as a result.[1]

This book had an enormous influence on me.  It was required reading for a program called the Oregon Extension, a four-month reading/study seminar in the mountains of Oregon, which I was planning to attend, after college.  In the end, I was in Oregon for only two nights and didn’t complete the program.  My grandmother became seriously ill and so I went home to New Jersey.  But I read the book, underlined most of it (in red), and finished reading it a year later, in 1987, in the waiting room of the Montclair Counseling Center in Montclair, New Jersey.  This novel threw me into an existential crisis, threw me into psychotherapy, which helped me to see the value of a therapeutic experience linked with faith, which continues today.

I thought about Pirsig and Zen this week as I reflected on John’s Gospel.  This is a remarkable part of John.  It’s Easter evening, the first day of the week.  We’re told that the doors of the house are locked, for fear.  We’re told that Jesus comes and stands among them and says, “Peace be with you.”  How did he get in?  He appears behind closed doors, locked doors.  He appears in the midst of their fear and says, “Peace.”  Jesus wasn’t there to shoot the breeze.  He was a man with a mission.  Ignoring their fear, he gets right to the point.  Jesus says, “As the Father has sent me, so I send you.”  As the Father sent the Son into the world, not to the condemn the world, but that the world might be saved through him (Jn.3:17), as God sent Jesus, so, now Jesus sends his disciples.

And not only does Jesus send his disciples to do the same work, earlier in John’s Gospel we have Jesus saying this: “Very truly, I tell you”—“very truly, I tell you,” meaning there’s no room for doubt about this, there’s nothing vague or ambiguous about this.  “Very truly, I tell you, the one who believes (that is, trusts) in me will also do the works that I do and, in fact, will do greater works than these, because I am going to the Father” (Jn. 14:12).  Not the same as Jesus, but greater, greater works!

And so, Jesus says, post-resurrection, “As the Father has sent me, so I send you.” And, “When he had said this, he breathed on them and said to them, ‘Receive the Holy Spirit’” (Jn. 20:22).  This is John’s version of Pentecost, without the tongues of fire and the hearing of many languages (see Acts 2).  The Spirit is given on the day of resurrection.  And, according to John’s Gospel, Jesus bestowed the Holy Spirit in a unique way.  He breathed on his disciples.  In both Hebrew and Greek the words for “breath,” “spirit,” and “wind” can all be used interchangeably.  God’s spirit is a breath that gives life.  God’s breath animates God’s people. God’s spirit as wind moves people.

All of which means—although the text doesn’t say it, it’s implied—that when Jesus breathed, they inhaled his breath.  They inhaled the holy.  They breathed in, took into themselves something of Jesus’ presence and power and breath and life.  Jesus bestows upon them—upon us—the life of God.  He brings us to life, true life, meaningful, abundant life (Jn. 10:10). Jesus is so close.  So intimate. Sharing breath.  That’s how close God is to us.  God in us, made flesh in us, dwelling in us, full of grace and truth (see Jn. 1:1-15).  When we know this, when we’re aware of this breath permeating our souls, when we feel this spirit/breath/wind moving through us and moving us, there’s no telling what we can do or accomplish or experience.

This brings me back to Pirsig.  Pirsig called this “gumption.”[2]  He turned to this old Scots word, used a lot by pioneers, to describe this element of the religious life.  He writes, “I like the world ‘gumption’ because it’s homely and so forlorn and so out of style it looks as if it needs a friend and isn’t likely to reject anyone who comes along.  …I like it also because it describes exactly what happens to someone who connects with Quality.  He gets filled with gumption.  The Greeks called it enthusiasmos, the root of ‘enthusiasm,’ which means literally ‘filled with theos,’ or God, or Quality.”

He says, “A person filled with gumption doesn’t sit around dissipating and stewing about things.  He’s at the front of the train of his own awareness, watching to see what’s up the track and meeting it when it comes.  That’s gumption.”

“The gumption-filling process occurs when one is quiet long enough to see and hear and feel the real universe, not just one’s own stale opinions about it. But it’s not exotic. That’s why I like the word,” Pirsig writes.

“You see it often in people who return from long, quiet fishing trips.  Often they’re a little defensive about having put so much time to ‘no account’ because there’s no intellectual justification for what they’ve been doing.  But the returned fisherman usually has a peculiar abundance of gumption, usually for the very same things he was sick to death of a few weeks before.  He hasn’t been wasting time.  It’s only our limited cultural viewpoint that makes it seem so.”

“Gumption is the psychic gasoline that keeps the whole thing going.  If you haven’t got it there’s no way the motorcycle can possibly be fixed. But if you have got it and know how to keep it there’s absolutely no way in this whole world that motorcycle can keep from getting fixed.  It’s bound to happen.  Therefore the thing that must be monitored at all times and persevered before anything else is gumption.”

What’s true for motorcycles is true for our lives, our souls, is true for the church, for this church.  Gumption.  Enthusiasmos. Enthusiasm.  God-filled.  Filled with the Holy Spirit.  The Spirit, Jesus, breathing through us.  Without the Spirit, there would be no church.  Without the Spirit, we wouldn’t be here today.  Christianity would have dissolved away like smoke, millennia ago. Without the Spirit, we wouldn’t know a thing about God or Christ or grace or love or the call of God in our lives and in the world.

On this Sunday, as we ordain and install new officers, we affirm the Holy Spirit’s role in all of this: through the work of the Nominating Committee, the Session, the congregation, the individuals who said yes to the call.  We will ask the Holy Spirit to come and rest upon these individuals in a unique and effective way—we will ask for gumption, the gumption to serve with courage and energy, intelligence, imagination, and love. 

And then we will hear from Alex Hall, who will announce this year’s Envision Fund Grants, totaling close to $115,000, shaping the ministry of this church and beyond these walls. And don’t underestimate for a minute that the Holy Spirit hasn’t been involved in this process either, in the grant writing, in the prayerful deliberative gumption of the board, and in the remarkable work we will be able to do, in the name of Christ—and dare I say, “greater works” than Jesus.  We’re about to do amazing work in a hospital in Haiti.  Jesus never set foot in Haiti. And yet we will help countless souls, bringing healing and wholeness and hope, all done in and through and with Jesus.  In John’s Gospel, we see that Jesus has enormous confidence in his disciples.  It absolutely astonishes me when I consider that Jesus actually trusts us and entrusts to us this ministry, this work.

The good news, friends, is that Jesus is still breathing through us, calling us, equipping us, the sending us out into the world to be God’s beloved people, with gumption.  So, go ahead, inhale.



Image: Nalini Jayasuriya, Receive the Holy Spirit.
[1] Robert M. Pirsig obituary in The New York Times.  
[2] Robert M. Pirsig, Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance: An Inquiry into Values (Toronto: Bantam Books, 1983), 272ff.



16 April 2017

Mary's Turn


Resurrection of the Lord

We owe Mary Magdalene an enormous debt of gratitude.  No, she's not a woman with a questionable past, although the Church has slandered her for centuries.[1]  No, she didn’t anoint Jesus’ feet with her hair; that was a different Mary, Mary of Bethany, brother of Lazarus (Jn. 12:1-8).  No, she didn’t have a reputation. No, she wasn’t a seductress—despite how Mary Magdalene is portrayed in Jesus Christ Superstar, singing to herself, “I Don’t Know How to Love Him.”[2] And there’s Dan Brown’s The Da Vinci Code (2003), who suggests that Jesus had a marital relationship with Mary Magdalene, and a family.[3]  Dan Brown was just playing with tall tales that are centuries old—and making a lot of money from it.  These images of Mary make good characters in musicals and fantasy novels, but they don’t reflect the Mary we find here in John.

So, no, she doesn't have a past.  In fact, we’ve only just met her. She first appears at the crucifixion— along with Mary, the wife of Clopas, and Jesus’ mother (Jn. 19:25). Three Marys.  We meet Mary Magdalene at the cross and then next at the tomb. And it’s this link between cross and tomb, and John’s decision to make Mary the main character (apart from Jesus, of course), which is significant and should grab our attention. 
           
First, we need to remember that in John’s Gospel everything—every word, image, metaphor, every character—is there for a reason. Nothing’s by mistake. So, this morning, I’m going to stay very close to the text.  Everything matters.  Everything is intentional.  So, wake up, pay attention, to what John is saying here about Mary’s experience, about resurrection, about Jesus. 

In hearing or reading this text on countless Easter Sundays—"Early on the first day of the week, while it was still dark, Mary Magdalene came to the tomb and saw that the stone had been removed from the tomb” (Jn. 20:1)—natural for us to focus on the moved stone and empty tomb.  But we need to notice right away that it’s Mary Magdalene who first discovers the remnants of resurrection. Mary.  Not the Beloved Disciple, not Peter.  Mary.

She runs to fetch Peter and the Beloved Disciple. They return together to see for themselves.  They find the tomb just as Mary described it.  Empty.  The linen wrappings are left neatly on the side of the grave slab. They’re flummoxed, confused, and then leave the scene, shaken by everything—so shaken they ignore Mary.  But we can’t ignore her.

Mary remained.  Mary remained in her grief.  She stood there, outside the tomb.  That’s what grief often feels like, doesn’t it?  You can’t move.  You’re stuck.  She stood.  Weeping.  Instead of running from grief (as the men did), Mary courageously faces hers.  John tells us, “As she wept,”—still weeping!—“she bent over to look into the tomb” (Jn. 20:11b).  This is remarkable—in the midst of her heartache she is courageous and strong enough to face the source of her sorrow, that which has broken her heart.  She enters into the place where death lives.  She goes into the dark tomb looking for Jesus. Although knowing his absence, her eyes still strain to find him; her eyes guide her forward into the tomb.  Her grief is leading her. 

In the tomb, she witnesses two angels sitting where Jesus once was—one at the head and one at the feet, John wants us to know (Jn. 20:12).  The angels intentionally frame the place of absence.  They “hold” the space between them, this place where Jesus once was and is no more. And, what comes to mind when we hear of something being flanked by two angels?  Anything? The “mercy seat” of YHWH, or kapporet, was the golden lid placed on the top of the Ark of the Covenant; it was flanked by two cherubim, with empty space between them, “locating” the dwelling place of YHWH (Exodus 25:17-22). The cherubim on the Ark frame or “hold” holiness, creating a space for the dwelling of the invisible, non-representable, non-possessable Living God.[4] In the tomb, Jesus “fills” the holy space with his absence.

With great respect the angels ask, “Woman,”—a word used earlier in the Gospel to refer to Jesus’ mother (Jn. 2:4)—“why are you weeping?” (Jn. 20:14).  She answers.  She says she was searching for Jesus’ body.  At that moment, John tells us, “she turned around and saw Jesus standing there” (Jn. 20:14), but she didn’t recognize him.  Then Jesus says to her, “Woman,”—again, so much respect—“why are you weeping? Whom are you looking for?” (Jn. 20:15).  Assuming him to be the gardener, she doesn’t see him.  She’s too concerned with finding a dead body.

Jesus says to her, “Mary!”  And, then, what does John tell us? Remember, every detail matters.  “She turned and said to him, ‘Rabbouni, Teacher’” (Jn. 20:16).  Isn’t this odd?  “She turned.”[5]  Wasn’t she already facing him, the gardener/Jesus?   Something so simple can be so profound.  She had already turned once, turned around to see what she thought was the gardener; but that turn was insufficient. She had to turn again.  But this was not the turn of the head or the body, but the turn of the heart.  And it’s with this second turning, the turn of the heart, the turn of “Aha!”, the turn that comes with revelation, recognition, realization, which allows the blind to see, the lost to be found, and the dead to come to life.  What’s required in us is the second turn. Without this turn, we can see but still be blind.  Without the turn, we’re left with an empty tomb, and the gardener, but no Jesus.  With the turning, everything changes.

So, how does this happen? What prepared Mary to hear the divine voice and see the Risen Lord before her?  Perhaps it was her tears.  The only other person who weeps in John’s Gospel is Jesus, when he sees the mourners weeping over the death of his friend Lazarus.  We’re told that Jesus was deeply disturbed by their grief, to the point that he was shaking and shuddering (Jn. 11:33). His tears pave the way for resurrection.  “Take away the stone,” Jesus said (Jn.11:39).  Tears, moved stones, and empty graves link these stories together.  Here, Mary Magdalene weeps for Jesus. Her tears pave the way for her to encounter resurrection.

What if it’s grief that prepares Mary to make the turn?  What if it’s her sorrow?  Her grief became the portal, which guided her into a dark tomb and beyond it.  Her grief, her sorrow, her tears, was the door, a holy threshold leading her to experience resurrection.  It’s her confrontation with loss and absence, her unwillingness to turn from her pain, her persistence, her determination, which allows her to move through absence to see the Lord of Life, not in a cemetery, we’re told, but in a garden (Jn. 19:41). We see that her grief, all along, was being held by resurrection, held by the Resurrected One, who makes space for her tears but never allows them to have the final word.

Thank you, Mary Magdalene, for showing us how to face our sorrow and embrace resurrection.  The first preacher of the resurrection.  The first to encounter the Risen Lord—without the Church or an institution, without tradition, without the aid of church school teachers.  She had no one, nothing.  She had nothing but her love and her grief, which was deep because of her love.  Astonishing.  I can’t help but wonder, what if Mary Magdalene had been the first Pope, instead of Peter?  A blasphemous thought, perhaps.  That doesn’t mean it isn’t true.  Patriarchy has been disastrous for us.  The Church and the history of the West, along with the rest of the world, would have been very different had we listened to John’s Gospel and gave more space to the feminine and the witness of women.[6]  Mary models a different way for us to be disciples, a different way for us to see.

Sometimes it’s grief, sorrow, sadness, even suffering which prepares us to make the turn, to encounter resurrection, which opens our eyes to see God’s presence standing before us in surprising, startling ways.  Sometimes it’s beauty that opens our eyes to see resurrection. Sometimes it’s hearing your name called by someone who loves you through and through.  Resurrection can be encountered through doubt, as Thomas knew (Jn. 20:19-29). Or, resurrection can show up at daybreak to grill you some fish for breakfast, as John tells us (Jn. 21:4-14).  

Mary Magdalene teaches us to look for the Risen Lord precisely in those places of loss and sadness, in our tears, weeping for what might have been, for lost opportunities, regrets, wrongs, weeping for ourselves, those we love, weeping for the world.  Christ promises to meet us in those places.  

Isn’t this what we’re saying when we declare, “Christ is risen!”? For the one who said, “I am Resurrection.  I am Life.” (Jn. 11:25), holds life and death, all of it, the abandonment and abyss of the cross, all the pain and grief of the world, even the depths of hell itself—holds all of it—and holds all of us with the fierce, yet tender love of God, a love that will never, ever let us go. 

Christ is risen! 

Alleluia!

Thanks be to God!






Image:
1. Edward Coley Burne-Jones (1833-1898), The Morning of Resurrection (1882).

2. Saint Mary Magdalene icon, (11th century), Monastery Dionysiou, Mount Athos, Greece.

[1] For example, Pope Gregory (d. 604) preached in a sermon, in 591, “She whom Luke calls the sinful woman, whom John calls Mary we believe to be the Mary from whom seven devils were ejected.” Cited in Jaime Clark-Soles, Reading John for Dear Life: A Spiritual Walk with the Fourth Gospel (Louisville: Westminster John Knox Press, 2016), 133.
[2] Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice, Jesus Christ Superstar (1970).
[3] Dan Brown, The Da Vinci Code (Anchor Books, 2009).
[4] Rowan Williams, “Between the Cherubim: The Empty Tomb and the Empty Throne,” On Christian Theology (Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, 2000), 187.
[5] I am indebted to Jaime Clark-Soles (137), for drawing my attention to the significance of the second “turn” in John 20.  The sermon circumambulates around this insight.
[6] The integration of the feminine into the psyche of the Christian experience is slowly occurring, but there’s still more healing or “therapy” required.  The psychologist C. G. Jung (1875-1961) was among the first to point the Church, and its theologies, in this direction toward deeper wholeness.  See Murray Stein, Jung’s Treatment of Christianity: The Psychotherapy of a Religious Tradition (Chiron Publications, 1986), 183ff.