07 October 2018

Only Connect


John 15:1-17

World Communion Sunday

On this World Communion Sunday we celebrate connection—with Christ, with neighbor, with creation. Jesus said, “Abide in me as I abide in you” (Jn. 15:4). Today, we are conscious of our connection to the global church.  To be part of the church of Jesus Christ means we are all connected, whether we like it or not.  We’re in this together.  And we need each other to be faithful to Christ. We can’t “do” church or “be” church on our own.  We can’t be faithful to Christ on our own.  We need each other.

When describing the Christian life, Latin American liberation theologians often talk about convivencia. Con-viva.  With life.  Convivencia means, literally, “living-with.”[1] Convivence is what sustains us individually and together, as a community. We are living with one another and living with the Lord.

Before Jesus died, he gave his followers an image to hold on to, especially when things get rough.  He gave them the image of vines and branches.  It’s a powerfully dynamic symbol.  Jesus invites us to abide in him, as branch to vine, because he wants to abide in us.  “Those who abide in me and I in them bear much fruit; apart from me you can do nothing” (John 15:5). He is the life force, the love that energizes the growth and brings about the yield, the fruit. And the relationship itself is fructifying.

In August, Mark and I were on vacation in California.  We spent a lot time in and near vineyards, visiting wineries in Napa Valley and in the Foothills of the Sierra Nevada, and we were invited to attend the Blessing of the Grapes ceremony hosted by the Livermore Valley Winegrower’s Association, an annual event held the beginning of harvest season.  They already had their clergy line-up for the event, but I was added to the program.  There was one rabbi, one priest, and two Presbyterian ministers.  It was a lot of fun.  I’ve never done anything like this before.  Even the local NBC affiliate showed up.  The blessing was held at Murietta’s Well, a beautiful winery in the Livermore Valley, followed by a marvelous luncheon.  We each shared a little about the importance of grapes and vine in our respective traditions.

I spoke about my experience walking on the Camino de Santiago in Spain, two years ago around this time. In the Rioja region, the Camino cuts around and sometimes straight through acres upon acres of vineyards.  On Sunday, September 25, I left Logroño when it was still dark. The city was recovering from its annual Rioja Festival, a weekend revel to the grape, worthy of Dionysius or Bacchus. On the way, I walked through and along and around many vineyards, as far as the eye could see.  As I walked, this text in John came to mind.  Up close to the vines, I could see the green, leafy branches were full of deep, purple grapes.  The branches led to old, knotty vines that thickened at the base where they sunk down deep into the soil.  I went to worship that morning, but not in a church.  I worshipped and prayed and sang my way along the way, out there among the vines and branches.  “I am the vine and you are the branches.”  I plucked off several grapes to eat; they were juicy and sweet.  I could feel the vitality of life all around me.  As I walked, I reflected on the nature of the vine. I considered the power of the vine—the source of life, the source of vitality for the branches. I considered the energy, all the life flowing through the vineyards, moving from the roots and stretching out along the branches and eventually bearing fruit.  Then I considered all the wine these grapes would eventually produce, barrels and barrels.  It felt as if wine was flowing all around me.  I was swimming in it.

The Greek verb meno, translated, “abide,” also means “to remain” or “remain on,” “hold,” “attach, “keep.”  It’s found in 16 of 21 chapters in John’s Gospel, used more than forty times.  Abide. Remain. Stay. Connect. Jesus says earlier in John, “Those who eat my flesh and drink my blood abide in me, and I in them” (Jn. 6:56).  Jesus uses a relational figure of speech and gives it to the disciples—gives to us—to encourage them, encourage us, to stay close to the vine. He wants us to stay near the Source of Life. Stay. Remain connected. Rest. Abide.

When Jesus says, “I am the true vine,” he is essentially saying, “I carry the roots.”[2]  He provides access to something deeper, deep in the soil.  He conveys through his roots the stuff of life, which generates growth. Through him the branches are generated, branches that intertwine and reach out in every direction.  We are the branches, tangled together, connected to each other and to the root.  A branch can’t survive cut from the vine; a branch can’t access the roots except through the vine.  A branch can’t go it alone, without withering and dying.  And a branch can’t choose to not be a branch, it can’t sever itself from the vine, because the branch is an outgrowth of the vine.  A branch cannot even hope to bear fruit apart from the vine—only when the branch is in service to the vine, in relation to the vine, when life pours through it and branches out, only then does it yield fruit.  The branch exists to bear fruit, to produce a yield, but it can’t do so apart from the vine.

In the novel Howards Ends (1910), E. M. Forster (1879-1970) writes of the protagonist Margaret Schlegel, her life-philosophy was simple. “Only connect! That was the whole of her sermon. Only connect the prose and the passion, and both will be exalted, and human love will be seen at its height. Live in fragments no longer.” Only connect. Forster was skeptical and, at times, hostile toward Christianity (for good reasons). Yet, here he certainly captures what’s at the heart of the Christian life: only connect.

What became clear (or clearer) in that moment of grace, walking through the vineyards that Sunday in Spain, and again in California, is that every blessed thing is pulsating with life and that life is pouring through the vine and bringing life to the branches (to you and to me), and we get to be part of it all. We get to be part of it all!  And when I was in California for the blessing of the grapes, I realized that the vineyards bless us.  Vineyards, grapes, wine tap into a deep desire in the human soul, they speak to our deep longing to be rooted in and connected to something bigger than ourselves.  They bind us all together.  And this gives life. This life flows through the church, here, and there, and everywhere. Through Christ, the Vine, we are connected to every branch; every branch is connected back to the Vine. This is why, for all of its faults, the church of Jesus Christ invaluable today. Perhaps this is why I love World Communion Sunday, and find myself so grateful for the joy and privilege of meeting and visiting with Christians all around the world, with sisters and brother sin Christ. I need to be connected to the global church.  The global church has much to teach North American Christians how to be better followers of Christ. Yes, we are part of a large family. We’re all related.  we’re all connected.

And there's no better symbol of our connection than Communion. So let us come to the Table of the Lord, remembering again what is always true:
In Christ there is no east or west,
in him no south or north,
but one great fellowship of love
throughout the whole wide earth.[3]


[1] Cited in David Congdon, The God Who Saves: A Dogmatic Sketch (Eugene, OR: Cascade Books, 2016), 42.
[2] Jaime Clark-Soles, Reading John for Dear Life: A Spiritual Walk with the Fourth Gospel (Louisville: Westminster John Knox Press, 2016), 101.
[3] From the hymn “In Christ There is No East or West,” written in 1908, by John Arthur Dunkerley (1852-1941), otherwise known as John Oxenham.

30 September 2018

Giving Our All




In 390 BCE, the Gauls, an ancient Celtic people, sent an army to take the city of Rome.  The Gauls tried to sneak into the city early one morning. Near the sanctuary dedicated to the goddess Juno, on the Capitoline Hill, lived a flock of geese, kept in a courtyard.  As the Gauls approached the geese were startled and began to honk loudly.  The captain of the guard, sleeping near the courtyard, heard their ruckus and woke up.  He spread word about the impending invasion, brought in more troops, and saved the city.  Juno, the wife of Jupiter, was considered the queen of the gods and the most powerful goddess.  She was originally the goddess of marriage and childbirth, the protectress of women, patroness of female virtue, and the patron goddess of Rome.  The Roman General Marcus Furius Camillus built a temple on the hill in gratitude for protecting the city.  She was known as Juno Moneta, from moneo, which means “to warn.”  Geese soon became symbols of Moneta, the goddess of warning—from which we get the English word money.  Around 290 BCE, the first Roman mint was built adjacent to the temple to Juno Moneta and the coins, struck with the head of Juno Moneta, were called moneta.  She became known as the protector of money and the guardian of finances.

Money and mint both evolved out of this ancient temple and mythos.  The myth taps into or reflects the way money is viewed as a god.  The myth also reminds us there’s something about money that is inherently alarming.  “Ever since the invention of Money, people have had to guard and defend it.  Now there was something worth stealing and an alarm to be sounded that we all must heed.”[1]

We remain enthralled to this myth, even if we don’t believe in the gods.  We do.  Money is a god.  It’s worshipped and praised by many.  If we’re not worshiping money or wealth, we certainly know the anxiety we feel around money, and alarm that it brings.  We’re anxious about having enough, about where it’s going to come from, and we worry about it being taken away or stolen.  Sometimes people who have more than they need and are at little risk of losing it are the most anxious.  People who have little or nothing have a different kind of anxiety, anxiety and fear that are justified and real.  Fear and anxiety over money can be devastating and dehumanizing and producing a lot of shame. 

Our two texts this morning, from Deuteronomy and 2 Corinthians, are two of many in the Bible that offers a very different attitude toward money and wealth and giving.  They form the foundation for a theology of stewardship that calls into question our views of money and wealth that trade in anxiety; these texts offer a different way, a way that is liberating and life-giving.

We begin, not with money, but with God.  God is always the starting point. We started with the great Shema, “Hear, O Israel, The LORD is our God, and the LORD alone. You shall love the LORD your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your might” (Deut. 6:4-5). Write this on your heart.  Inscribe it on your forehead. Mark it over the lintel of the door.  Don’t forget.  Remember.

What should we remember?  “Remember what the LORD—Yahweh—has done for you, remember the promise he swore to your ancestors to Abraham and Sarah, Isaac and Rebecca, and Jacob and Rachel and Leah.  When you enter into the land of promise, which did not belong to you, which was given to you as gift, and live in large cities, which you did not build, houses filled with all sorts of goods that you did not fill, hewn cisterns that you did not hew, vineyards and olive groves that you did not plant—and when you have eaten your fill, take care that you do not forget the LORD, who brought you out of the place of slavery. The LORD you shall fear, the LORD you shall serve, the LORD and the LORD alone is owed your loyalty (Deut. 6:10-13).

This text, and others like it, reminds us of the givenness of things, of all that we have but didn’t earn, is, like grace, a gift.  We are reminded of the prevenience of grace, the fact that grace is always prior, it always come first. The gift, that which has been given to us, is always first.  We don’t create the world, we are born into a world that is already here. When you consider the world, the gift of human existence, the gift of your life, the gift of God’s grace which has saved you and continues to save you and redeem you and make you whole, when you consider all that has been given to you—do not forget the Adonai.  Then let your worship, your life, your service be in response to the prevenient grace, to what has already been given to us. Give of yourself.

“The one who sows sparingly will also reap sparingly,” Paul said, “and the one who sows bountifully will also reap bountifully.”  Put in a little, then expect little.  Invest generously, expect a generous yield.  How you give, what you give is between you and God, whatever you decide, whatever your conscience dictates.  What matters most is that we give not reluctantly or under compulsion, not because it’s what’s expected of us, not because we have to, but because we want to.  This might not sound all that radical, but it was.  Because what you need to know is that in Roman society, which was extremely patriarchal and hierarchical, generosity and gratitude were often forced.  People were expected to express their gratitude to the emperor for what the emperor provides.  In this patron-client system, a patron provided protection, money, access to power in exchange for the client’s loyalty, allegiance, and thanksgiving.  Giving was not free.  It had conditions.  Protection, money, and access were given only when you promised loyalty and gratitude.[2]  It was an even exchange. The amount given was proportional to the response received.

However, what Paul is suggesting here about giving undercuts, even undermines the patron-client system.  We don’t give reluctantly, not because we must to be safe and secure.  That’s not motivating us. We give because we want to, because giving should be a matter of the heart.

Where’s your heart? Is your heart in it? God want us to give—whatever we give—from love. God wants us to give because we want to, because it brings us joy knowing that through what we give we are bringing joy to the world.  “God loves a cheerful giver” (2 Cor. 9:7).  The Greek is actually hilaritas.  In the Greco-Roman world, the goddess Hilaritas was the personification of cheerfulness, rejoicing, and mirth. She’s often seen holding a cornucopia, a horn of plenty, signifying abundance.  This is the root of the English word hilarity.  A better translation would be, “God loves a hilarious giver.” God wants your hilarity. You know what’s it’s like to be around someone who is hilarious, she causes you to laugh and laugh, and when you’re laughing with joy, it just flows and flows from a deep place; it’s there in abundance.

That’s what giving is like in the Christian life.  The apostle Paul is often described as the theologian of grace because he knew, first-hand, the transforming power of God’s grace, made real for him in the face of Jesus Christ.  When Paul experienced the enormous generosity of God’s love and grace toward him, it released something enormously generous and generative in him.  When we encounter this grace, when we experience it, when we’re pursued by grace, we discover that we are free to be generous because there’s more than enough to go around, there’s never any risk of losing what we have, because, technically-speaking, we don’t have anything that really belongs to us.  We’re drinking from cisterns that we haven’t hewn. So we are free to share.  “And God is able,” said Paul, “to provide you with every blessing in abundance, so that by always having enough of everything, you may share abundantly in every good work” (2 Cor. 9:8).

Grace and gratitude.[3] These two words pretty much sum up the Christian life. The more we experience God's generous grace toward us, the more our hearts are moved to respond with gratitude. Just as grace is experienced in a variety of ways in our lives, so, too, is gratitude.

But sometimes there’s a “gratitude gap.”  That’s what contemporary religion scholar Diana Butler Bass describes in her recently released book Grateful: The Transformative Power of Giving Thanks. This past week The Presbyterian Foundation hosted a stewardship conference in St. Louis where Bass was one of the keynote speakers.  I wish I could have been there, but I followed online.  Back in 2015, she came across a disturbing statistic in a study conducted by the Pew Forum.  The survey indicated that 78 percent of Americans said they had experienced gratitude within the past week.  “Seventy-eight percent is an extraordinarily high number,” she said.  “I sat for a moment with that and thought, ‘Wow that’s really wonderful that eight out of 10 Americans say they’ve felt strongly grateful in the last seven days.” She said, “Wow,” but then asked, “Am I one of the 78 or one of the 22?”[4] This began her exploration of gratitude; she wanted to be more grateful in her life.

There are two important aspects of gratitude that she unearthed in her research.  First, she found that American men are uncomfortable with the concept of gratitude. Why? “Being strongly indoctrinated in the importance of being ‘self-made,’ men find it an insult to be told they didn’t accomplish their feats alone. “No one gives me anything.” “I do it myself.”  “I earned it myself.” “I don’t owe anyone anything.”  This is the prize narrative in our culture and has influenced American men. This attitude has shaped how we view gratitude. But, remember, we live in cities that we didn’t build, drink from cisterns that we did not hew, enjoy the fruit of vines which we did not plant.

For all of us, Bass believes, there is within American society a “gratitude gap.” Most of us know that gratitude is good. Being grateful is actually good for us.  Still, there is a gap between our desire to be grateful and our ability to behave gratefully. We might feel personally grateful, but we fail to convey our gratitude in a public way, and this is adversely affecting our personal and public lives.  Bass has found that, “Being grateful does not appear to make much difference in our larger common life.”  This has enormous implications for society and institutions, including the church. How do we move from private gratitude to public gratitude?

In Marilynne Robinson's novel Gilead, the ailing Congregationalist minister John Ames tells his son, “There is more beauty than our eyes can bear, precious things have been put into our hands and to do nothing to honor them is to do great harm.”[5]  I love this sentence.  I love Gilead, it’s one of my favorite novels.  I love Marilynn Robinson’s writings, she’s a person of deep faith and searing insight and a great lover of John Calvin (1509-1564)—she understands Calvin better than most.  Calvinist or Reformed theology is imbued throughout her works, including Gilead, especially this one sentence.  

This sentence beautifully sums up the Reformed claim that grace and gratitude are at the heart of the Christian life.  And Calvin wrote quite a lot about beauty.[6]  Beauty is all around us, more than our eyes can bear, beauty not of our own making, prevenient beauty. Given to us.  Indeed, much—so much—has been given to us.  Precious things have been put into our hands, entrusted to us, and to do nothing to honor them, to fail to acknowledge them, to use them, to share them, even to give them away, is to do great harm.  This is a profound insight—and it haunts me, actually. To withhold our gratitude, to not be generous with what has been placed into our hands, into our lives, into our bank accounts, especially when we have the capacity to be more grateful and generous, is to do great harm. We cut, we sever the grace-gratitude connection, and our souls suffer as a result.

“Hear, O Israel: The LORD is our God, and the LORD alone. You shall love the LORD your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your might” (Deut. 6:4-5). All.  Not some.  Not a little. Not enough. All.

With gratitude, we are call to be good stewards of our time, talent, and treasure.  Being a good steward is to honor what has been given to us.  It means not holding back.  We are free to be hilariously generous with our time, talent, and treasure. But woe to us when we prefer to be too cautious, when we hold back, when we withhold, when anxiety and fear take control of our lives.  

Where in our lives are we holding back our time, our talents, and our treasure?   Where can we be more generous with our time? Not because we have to, but because we want to?  Where does the heart want to be more generous?  How can we be more generous with our gifts—to really use them and not hide them under a bushel? Where can we be more generous with our financial resources to do more good in the world?  What harm are we doing, often unintentionally, by holding back or withholding our time, our talents, our gifts, our love?

Gratitude takes many forms. What matters most is that we respond to the gift of grace, and not hold back.





[1] Aaron R. Kipnis, The Midas Complex: How Money Drives Us Crazy and What We Can Do about It (2013).
[2] Diana Butler Bass, Grateful: The Transformative Power of Giving (HarperOne, 2018).
[3] See Brian Gerrish’s brilliant text Grace and Gratitude: The Eucharistic Theology of John Calvin
[4] Presbyterian Foundation, Stewardship Kaleidoscope, September 25, 2018. 
[5] Marilynne Robinson, Gilead (Picador Books, 2006), 290
[6] On beauty in the Reformed tradition see Belden C. Lane, Ravished by Beauty: The Surprising Legacy of Reformed Spirituality (New York: Oxford University Press, 2011).